A shop owner tells a court she saw a white car before a crash and says, 'The car seemed to be moving too fast for the street.' The opposing attorney challenges this testimony, arguing the shop owner cannot comment on the car's speed. Should this testimony be admitted as a lay opinion under the Federal Rules of Evidence?
The court should exclude it because the shop owner’s opinion lacks a clear basis in observable facts.
The court should allow it because eyewitness testimony is typically admissible in court.
The court should allow it because her statement reflects her personal observations and does not rely on specialized knowledge.
The court should exclude it because assessing vehicle speed before a crash often requires expert analysis.
Under Rule 701 of the Federal Rules of Evidence, a layperson can offer an opinion if it is rationally based on their perception, helpful to understanding their testimony or a fact in issue, and not grounded in scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge. The shop owner's statement about the car's speed is based on her own observations and does not require technical expertise, such as calculating exact velocity. Therefore, it is admissible as a lay opinion because it helps the fact-finder evaluate what she observed. Testimony would become inadmissible, however, if it involved speculation or lacked a clear connection to her perceptions. For example, if the shop owner had no opportunity to observe the car clearly, the objection might succeed. Expert testimony is generally necessary for more technical conclusions, such as precise speed calculations derived from physical evidence.
Ask Bash
Bash is our AI bot, trained to help you pass your exam. AI Generated Content may display inaccurate information, always double-check anything important.
What does Rule 701 of the Federal Rules of Evidence cover?
Open an interactive chat with Bash
Why is the shop owner's testimony considered admissible under Rule 701?
Open an interactive chat with Bash
When would a lay opinion about a car's speed require expert testimony instead?
Open an interactive chat with Bash
Multistate Bar Examination
Evidence
Your Score:
Report Issue
Bash, the Crucial Exams Chat Bot
AI Bot
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Pass with Confidence.
Bar Prep Package
You have hit the limits of our free tier, become a Premium Member today for unlimited access.
Military, Healthcare worker, Gov. employee or Teacher? See if you qualify for a Community Discount.
3 Month Pass
$299.99
$99.99/mo
One time purchase of $299.99, Does not auto-renew.
BEST DEAL
Lifetime Pass
$399.99
One time purchase, Good for life.
What You Get
All Bar Prep Package plans include the following perks and exams .