A pharmacist, who deeply resented his ex-business partner, decided to poison him by lacing a sugar substitute commonly used by the partner with a lethal dose of a toxic chemical. The pharmacist replaced the original sugar substitute in his partner's office with the poisoned version, expecting the partner to use it in his coffee the next morning. However, the partner noticed the packaging was tampered with and did not use it. Can the pharmacist be held criminally liable for attempting to poison the partner?
Yes, because swapping the sugar substitute was a substantial step toward completing the crime.
No, because the partner discovered the tampered packaging and never consumed the poison.
Yes, because the pharmacist had the intent to harm the partner, even though he failed to carry out the crime.
No, because the crime was not completed, and the poisoning did not occur.
The pharmacist can be held criminally liable for attempting to poison his partner because he committed an overt act beyond mere preparation for the crime by actually swapping the sugar substitute with a poisoned version. Merely planning or harboring an intent to commit a crime is insufficient; a person must take substantial steps toward the commission of the offense, demonstrating a clear intent to complete it. In this scenario, switching the packaging constitutes a substantial step. The incorrect answers involve misunderstandings about the boundaries of preparation versus attempt or an erroneous interpretation of mens rea (mental state) in attempt crimes.
Ask Bash
Bash is our AI bot, trained to help you pass your exam. AI Generated Content may display inaccurate information, always double-check anything important.
What is a 'substantial step' in criminal attempt?
Open an interactive chat with Bash
How does intent (mens rea) apply in attempt crimes?
Open an interactive chat with Bash
Why does the crime not need to be completed for attempt liability?
Open an interactive chat with Bash
Multistate Bar Examination
Criminal Law and Procedure
Your Score:
Report Issue
Bash, the Crucial Exams Chat Bot
AI Bot
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Pass with Confidence.
Bar Prep Package
You have hit the limits of our free tier, become a Premium Member today for unlimited access.
Military, Healthcare worker, Gov. employee or Teacher? See if you qualify for a Community Discount.
3 Month Pass
$299.99
$99.99/mo
One time purchase of $299.99, Does not auto-renew.
BEST DEAL
Lifetime Pass
$399.99
One time purchase, Good for life.
What You Get
All Bar Prep Package plans include the following perks and exams .